• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
New York Sports Today

New York Sports Today

New York Sports News Continuously updated

  • Football
    • Giants
    • Jets
    • Guardians
  • Baseball
    • Mets
    • Yankees
  • Basketball
    • Knicks
    • Nets
    • Liberty
  • Hockey
    • Devils
    • Islanders
    • Rangers
  • Soccer
    • Gotham FC
    • NYC FC
    • NYC FC 2
    • Red Bulls
    • Red Bulls 2
  • Colleges
    • Army
    • Fordham
    • Manhattan College
    • Rutgers
    • Seton Hall
    • St John’s
    • Syracuse
    • University of Connecticut
  • Team Stores

Sheldon Keefe Hasn’t Been Afraid of Being Critical of the New Jersey Devils…And That’s Good

November 6, 2025 by All About The Jersey

The New Jersey Devils West Coast road trip did not go the way anyone would have wanted it to. Despite a great win in LA this past Saturday, a 1-3-0 record isn’t good enough for a team looking to be a true contender. Not only did the team look poor in most of those defeats, but it also prevented them from increasing their point lead over the teams behind them in the standings. Instead of having a six to eight or so point lead on the teams trailing them, the Devils now find themselves with only four points separating them and the teams at the bottom of the division standings. Not only were fans rightfully calling them out, but so was Head Coach Sheldon Keefe.

A couple of different articles have come out during the team’s most recent streak of play featuring Keefe’s comments regarding the team’s efforts not being good enough. He’s mentioned lack or urgency, the effort not being good, and the outcome being what the team deserves, among other remarks made to the media. He even went so far as to say the team was playing, “a lot of really bad hockey” lately. After watching the games, I’m hard pressed to disagree with him as well.

Now maybe it seems strange to hear a coach calling out a team that is currently sitting high in the NHL standings. The Devils at time of writing are tied for third on overall points, and fifth on points percentage. Yet, I think it’s actually a good thing to hear Keefe being critical. While the focal points of his comments have leaned more towards the defense, he’s not singling anyone out, and seems to be holding the group accountable as a whole right now. Hopefully this is the wake up call they need and we don’t get to a point where individual names are needing to be dropped. An early wake-up call is better than a late one or one that never comes as well. If the Devils start to realize their faults now, and begin cleaning up those sooner rather than later, it should lead to fewer games with poor starts and zone collapses like we saw on the road trip.

While I’m okay with Keefe calling out the players, I do hope he’s holding his coaching staff (and himself) just as accountable. Coaching decisions, line combinations and player deployment also play roles in team performance; while a lot of the road trip issues came from poor on ice decisions, putting players in spots where they weren’t going to be effective didn’t help either. I know injuries are also affecting deployment right now (we miss you Brett Pesce, get well soon), but if Keefe is holding the available players accountable, he should also be holding himself and his staff accountable for their missteps.

Once again, I’m happy to see the team being looked at through a critical lens so early in the season. Not only does it show that the team is trying to improve, but I prefer the honesty over excuses. Saying we’re not good enough is better than “not our night” or “tough building” any day of the week. Sheldon Keefe is keeping his standards high for the team in alignment with expectations for this Devils squad. Now let’s just hope that the criticism propels the Devils past their current adversity to become a stronger, more consistent team.

What are your thoughts on Sheldon Keefe choosing to be critical now; are you happy that he did it early while the Devils are high in the standings, or would you rather he have waited? Do you think there should be more blame on players, or coaches, or should it be shared? Are you hopeful that the coaching staff recognizing the team’s deficiencies now will lead to them fixing the problems sooner? Leave any and all comments below and thanks as always for reading!

Filed Under: Devils

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Knicks’ $12 million dollar man has been a complete dud
  • How Jaxson Dart’s emergence opens up NFL draft options for the Giants
  • Mets have big decision to make on speedster before Rule 5 deadline
  • Blue Jays Targeting High-Leverage Relievers
  • Yankees linked to blockbuster trade for Tigers superstar ace

Categories

Archives

Our Partners

All Sports

  • 247 Sports
  • Bleacher Report
  • Elite Sports NY
  • Empire Sports Media
  • Empire Writes Back
  • MSG Networks
  • New York Daily News
  • New York Times
  • New York Post
  • Newsday
  • OurSports Central
  • SNY - SportsNet New York
  • The Sports Daily
  • The Sports Fan Journal
  • The Spun
  • USA Today
  • WFAN Sports Radio
  • YES Network

Baseball

  • MLB.com - Yankees
  • MLB.com - Mets
  • Amazin Avenue
  • Last Word On Baseball - Mets
  • Last Word On Baseball - Yankees
  • MLB Trade Rumors - Yankees
  • MLB Trade Rumors - Mets
  • Rising Apple
  • Yanks Go Yard

Basketball

  • NBA.com - Knicks
  • NBA.com - Nets
  • Amico Hoops - Knicks
  • Amico Hoops - Nets
  • Daily Knicks
  • Hoops Hype - Knicks
  • Hoops Hype - Nets
  • Hoops Rumors - Knicks
  • Hoops Rumors - Nets
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - New York Knicks
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - Brooklyn Nets
  • Nets Daily
  • Nets Wire
  • Nothing But Nets
  • Posting And Toasting
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Knicks
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Nets
  • Real GM - Knicks
  • Real GM - Nets

Football

  • New York Giants
  • New York Jets
  • Big Blue Interactive
  • Big Blue View
  • Gang Green Nation
  • Giants Gab
  • Giants Wire
  • Gmen HQ
  • Jets Fix
  • Jets Gab
  • Jet Nation
  • Jets Wire
  • Last Word On Pro Football - New York Giants
  • Last Word On Pro Football - New York Jets
  • NFL Trade Rumors - Giants
  • NFL Trade Rumors - Jets
  • Our Turf Football - Giants
  • Our Turf Football - Jets
  • Pro Football Focus - Giants
  • Pro Football Focus - Jets
  • Pro Football Rumors - Giants
  • Pro Football Rumors - Jets
  • Pro Football Talk - Giants
  • Pro Football Talk - Jets
  • The Gang Green
  • The Jet Press
  • Total Giants
  • Total Jets
  • Turn On The Jets
  • Ultimate NYG

Hockey

  • All About The Jersey
  • Blue Line Station
  • Blue Shirt Banter
  • Elite Prospects - Devils
  • Elite Prospects - Islanders
  • Elite Prospects - Rangers
  • Eyes On Isles
  • Last Word On Hockey - Devils
  • Last Word On Hockey - Islanders
  • Last Word On Hockey - Rangers
  • Lighthouse Hockey
  • Pro Hockey Rumors - Devils
  • Pro Hockey Rumors - Islanders
  • Pro Hockey Rumors - Rangers
  • Pro Hockey Talk - Devils
  • Pro Hockey Talk - Islanders
  • Pro Hockey Talk - Rangers
  • Pucks And Pitchforks
  • The Hockey Writers - Devils
  • The Hockey Writers - Islanders
  • The Hockey Writers - Rangers

Soccer

  • Last Word on Soccer - NYC FC
  • Last Word on Soccer - Red Bulls
  • Last Word on Soccer - Sky Blue FC
  • MLS Multiplex - NYC FC
  • MLS Multiplex - Red Bulls
  • Once A Metro

Colleges

  • Against All Enemies
  • Big East Coast Bias
  • Busting Brackets
  • College Football News
  • College Sports Madness
  • Forgotten 5
  • Inside The Loud House
  • Orange Fizz
  • Rumble In The Garden
  • Saturday Blitz
  • The Daily Orange
  • The UConn Blog
  • Troy Nunes Is An Absolute Magician
  • Zags Blog

Footer

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in