Aaron Rodgers was supposed to change everything for the New York Jets. The franchise went all-in on the veteran quarterback, hoping to end years of disappointment. Then, a season-ending Achilles injury crushed that vision before it had a chance to unfold. Now, questions about his future are louder than ever. The team is making moves behind the scenes, and Rodgers’ place in the picture looks uncertain.
Rodgers’ 2024 Season: A Tough Reality Check
Aaron Rodger’s arrival in New York certainly boosted expectations. The Jets went from a struggling team to one with legitimate playoff hopes, and odds by FanDuel reflected that optimism. But those expectations never matched the reality on the field.
The comeback was supposed to be a redemption story. Rodgers fought through months of rehab, determined to prove his career wasn’t over. But when he finally returned, reality hit hard. The offense never clicked. The throws weren’t as sharp. The movement wasn’t the same. Every game felt like a battle, and more often than not, the Jets came up short.
Rodgers showed glimpses of the player he used to be, a perfect pass here and an intelligent read there. But the consistency was gone. Maybe it was the offensive line struggling to protect him. Maybe it was the lack of elite weapons around him. Or maybe, something no one wants to say out loud, time has finally caught up to him.
That’s what makes this decision so difficult for the Jets. Rodgers isn’t just any quarterback. He’s one of the best to ever do it. But NFL teams don’t operate on nostalgia. They can’t afford to. If a quarterback isn’t producing, it doesn’t matter what he’s done in the past. The only thing that matters is what he can do now.
And right now, the Jets have to ask themselves: is Rodgers still capable of carrying this team? Or is keeping him just delaying the inevitable?
A Franchise Desperate for Playoff Success
No team in the league has gone longer without a playoff appearance. That’s a problem. Fans are tired of waiting, and the ownership knows it. The Rodgers experiment was meant to change that. It hasn’t.
Missing the playoffs again would make it hard to justify another year of the same plan. The AFC is stacked with young quarterbacks leading their teams to success. The Jets don’t want to watch another year slip away while hoping Rodgers suddenly turns things around. Fans are equally eager, not wanting to miss out on the Latest NFL Game Matchups at FanDuel.
The Contract Gives Them an Easy Exit
For a team in this position, money matters. Keeping Rodgers for 2025 means triggering a $35 million option bonus. Letting him go means freeing up cap space to go in another direction.
If the New York Jets cut Aaron Rodgers before June 1, 2025, the dead cap charge would be $49M. If they cut him after June 1, the dead cap charge would be $14M in 2025 and $35M in 2026.
If they bring him back, they bet another year will be different. If they move on, they’re admitting the gamble didn’t work. Neither choice is easy, but ignoring the question isn’t an option.
Fresh Leadership, Fresh Perspective
Whenever a team undergoes a major shakeup in the front office and coaching staff, one thing is almost guaranteed: significant roster changes. New decision-makers rarely want to inherit someone else’s plan, especially when that plan has already shown cracks. They come in with their ideas, philosophies, and blueprints for success.
Rodgers wasn’t their guy. They didn’t draft him. They didn’t trade for him. They weren’t part of the negotiations that brought him to New York. That matters.
For a new general manager, the priority is often long-term stability. That means evaluating everything through a different lens—not just asking if Rodgers can help the team win next season, but whether keeping him aligns with a sustainable future. If they see him as a short-term fix for a long-term problem, they may decide it’s time to move on.
Rodgers’ Own Future Is Unclear
This might not even be the Jets’ decision to make. Rodgers has kept his future open-ended, saying he needs time to think. That alone raises questions. Players who are fully committed don’t hesitate when asked about next season. They don’t leave room for doubt. They declare they’ll be back, ready to compete, and eager for another shot. Rodgers hasn’t done that.
He has spoken highly of his time in New York but hasn’t promised anything. He’s acknowledged that he won’t stand in their way if the team chooses a different direction. That’s not the stance of someone desperate to stay. It’s a player’s stance who might already be preparing for multiple possibilities.
What Comes Next?
There’s no easy answer. Keeping Rodgers for another year would mean betting that this past season was an outlier, not the new normal. Letting him go would mean admitting that the grand experiment didn’t work.
Neither choice is perfect. Sticking with Rodgers comes with risk, and so does moving on. The only sure thing is that the Jets can’t afford to keep waiting for things to fall into place magically. This franchise made a bold move when they brought Rodgers in. Now, they must decide if they’re willing to double down or if it’s time to walk away.
The post Are the Jets already planning for an Aaron Rodgers exit? appeared first on TheGangGreen.com.