Some moments in a baseball season feel like gut punches—and for the New York Yankees, this one left fans breathless.
Jake Cousins, a bright spot in the bullpen last year and a reliever with a golden arm, is out. Not just for 2025, but likely well into 2026.
The Yankees had revealed that he needed Tommy John surgery this week, ending hopes of a midseason return and launching a long road to recovery.
It’s the kind of injury news that feels like the baseball gods are playing hardball with New York’s bullpen depth.
A hopeful rehab turns into heartbreak
Cousins hadn’t thrown a pitch in the majors this season, but there was light at the end of the tunnel.
After battling elbow issues and a flexor strain diagnosed back in spring training, he began a rehab assignment. The hope was that he’d be a second-half weapon—an arm that could help bridge the gap in close games.
But that light dimmed quickly. The Yankees were forced to shut Cousins down during rehab, and after further evaluation, the reality hit hard: surgery was the only option left.
In true modern fashion, Cousins shared the update himself on Instagram, posting a message that tugged at the heartstrings of Yankees fans.
Cousins promises to come back stronger
“Thankful for a great TJ surgery yesterday with Dr. Meister and his team,” Cousins wrote on his Instagram account.
“On the way to recovery with the best at home care. Determined to come back better than ever!”
#Yankees RHP Jake Cousins underwent Tommy John surgery yesterday: pic.twitter.com/Qi8zkRBvlT
— Bryan Hoch ⚾️ (@BryanHoch) June 19, 2025
It’s the message of a fighter—of someone not ready to let injury define his career. And for fans who watched him dominate hitters last year, it’s both a painful reminder of what’s lost and a promise of what could return.
His 2024 dominance now feels like a distant dream
Cousins was electric in 2024, posting a dazzling 2.37 ERA over 38 innings. He struck out 53 hitters and gave the Yankees a reliable weapon in high-leverage situations.
Watching him work was like seeing a magician at the peak of his craft—every pitch unpredictable, every batter guessing. He didn’t just pitch well; he overwhelmed.
But baseball, like life, doesn’t always reward momentum. And now, just months removed from those memorable outings, Cousins found himself on a surgeon’s table and a long recovery timeline.
Don’t expect a return before 2027
With Tommy John surgery typically requiring 14–18 months of recovery, the timeline is grim.
Cousins won’t pitch again in 2025, and any return in 2026 would likely be a long shot. The most realistic scenario sees him taking the mound again in 2027, hopefully with a normal spring training under his belt.
Given the fact that 2026 is his first year of arbitration, the Yankees will still control his contract. It’s a sliver of long-term optimism in an otherwise bleak short-term picture.
Still, the waiting game has begun—and fans know all too well how slow that clock ticks when a key player is on the shelf.
The bullpen will feel his absence
With a team built around elite pitching, every missing piece stings—and Cousins was a cornerstone in the making.
His ability to strike out hitters, limit damage, and handle pressure situations gave the Yankees much-needed stability. In his absence, others will need to step up.
But there’s no easy way to replace what Cousins brought. His presence, his energy, and his performance made him a fan favorite.
Now, the bullpen must regroup—and hope reinforcements arrive via trade or internal development.
A long journey ahead, but hope remains
If recovery from Tommy John surgery is a marathon, Cousins just left the starting line. It’ll be months before he throws a ball again, and longer still before he faces live hitters.
But the pitcher’s mindset—grounded in resilience and faith—gives fans something to root for beyond the box score.
And in baseball, hope never truly fades. It just waits for its next turn at bat.
Popular reading:
Yankees could get big bullpen weapon back as soon as tomorrow
!function(){var g=window;g.googletag=g.googletag||{},g.googletag.cmd=g.googletag.cmd||[],g.googletag.cmd.push(function(){g.googletag.pubads().setTargeting(“has-featured-video”,”true”)})}();