The Yankees couldn’t hold on against the Toronto Blue Jays on Monday, dropping a tense 5–4 contest that stung for more reasons than one.
It wasn’t just the scoreboard that had fans worried. Trent Grisham, one of their most pleasant surprises this year, left the game early.
Watching him jog off with tightness in his left hamstring felt like a gut punch for a team already clinging to their AL East lead.
Grisham’s impact has been bigger than anyone expected
Manager Aaron Boone has leaned heavily on Grisham, slotting him into the leadoff spot and trusting his eye to spark rallies.
This season, Grisham is hitting .246 with a .348 OBP and a .467 slugging mark, good for an .815 OPS that ranks among career bests.
He’s mashed 15 homers and driven the Yankees’ offense forward with his incredible plate discipline — ranking in the 99th percentile in chase rate.
His blend of patience and power has given the lineup a whole new dimension. It’s almost like he’s become the silent engine under the hood.
Losing Grisham now would pile on problems
The Yankees have needed every bit of Grisham’s consistency. He’s allowed Boone to rotate and rest Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and others.
Without him, the Yankees would suddenly be stretched thin, especially with their recent run-scoring troubles and bench pieces offering limited production.
This isn’t just about resting stars — Grisham has actually carried them at times, coming up with clutch hits and setting the table beautifully.
It’s hard to understate how much tougher Boone’s job becomes if Grisham’s hamstring requires more than a day or two off.
Yankees desperately need his bat in the lineup
Grisham’s profile this year is everything the Yankees crave. His 15 homers pair perfectly with a sharp eye and steady on-base skills.
He’s also slugging the ball with authority, sporting advanced metrics that back up the breakout season. This isn’t just a lucky hot streak.
The fact he ranks so high in chase and hard-hit stats shows a hitter who knows exactly what he wants to do at the plate.
It’s no coincidence Boone’s been writing Grisham’s name at the top of the lineup card nearly every day — he’s earned that trust.
- Yankees’ star prospect is flashing elite upside but there’s still one major red flag
- Yankees holding their breath as breakout outfielder suffers hamstring injury
- Yankees 4, Blue Jays 5: Good news and bad news following sloppy defensive and bullpen showing
Can the Yankees stay afloat if Grisham misses time?
There’s no official word yet on the severity, but hamstring injuries are tricky, especially for players who rely on quick bursts.
The Yankees are in a tight race in the AL East, and losing Grisham for even two weeks could change the entire dynamic.
Right now, he’s one of their most important bats. That sounds wild considering where he started this season, but it’s the truth.
!function(){var g=window;g.googletag=g.googletag||{},g.googletag.cmd=g.googletag.cmd||[],g.googletag.cmd.push(function(){g.googletag.pubads().setTargeting(“has-featured-video”,”true”)})}();