Clarke Schmidt left the mound on Thursday with a sore forearm, but the blow hit the New York Yankees’ heart.
What began as forearm tightness in Schmidt’s start against the Toronto Blue Jays has spiraled into devastating news.
The 28-year-old right-hander exited after just three innings, having allowed four hits and three runs on noticeably diminished stuff.
Yankees fans feared the worst — and manager Aaron Boone confirmed it postgame with the words no pitcher wants to hear.
According to YES Network’s Jack Curry, Schmidt is “likely” headed for Tommy John surgery, ending his 2025 season prematurely.
Clarke Schmidt will likely require Tommy John surgery, Boone just told reporters. Awful news for Schmidt and Yankees.
— JackCurryYES (@JackCurryYES) July 5, 2025
It’s a brutal development for Schmidt, who entered the year with momentum and had finally found consistency in the Bronx.
Despite beginning the season on the IL with shoulder tendinitis, Schmidt had rebounded with an impressive 3.32 ERA over 14 starts.
He had become a stabilizing force in a Yankees rotation riddled with uncertainty long before Saturday’s grim diagnosis.
With Gerrit Cole out for the year, Luis Gil still shelved, and Ryan Yarbrough also out, Schmidt’s loss stings all the more.
There’s no sugarcoating it — the Yankees’ once-promising rotation is now patchwork, and the timing couldn’t be worse.
Schmidt’s Emergence Was a Bright Spot Amid Injuries
Schmidt wasn’t just pitching well — he was growing into the role the Yankees envisioned when they drafted him in the first round.
Armed with underrated stuff and increasingly confident mound presence, Schmidt had started to feel like a long-term piece.
His ERA wasn’t empty — he was inducing weak contact, limiting walks, and showing signs of real command development.
Every fifth day, Schmidt gave the Yankees a real shot to win, something that can’t be said for all remaining options.
The Yankees now find themselves in a dangerous spot — competing for the AL East with a decimated starting five.
Rotation Depth Now Faces an Emergency Test
Replacing Clarke Schmidt internally isn’t going to be easy, and it’s clear the Yankees will need to get creative.
Journeymen like Allan Winans or JT Brubaker could serve as temporary Band-Aids, but neither offers long-term reliability.
Winans has pitched well in Triple-A, but he lacks Schmidt’s stuff or strike-throwing consistency against big-league hitters.
Brubaker, returning from Tommy John himself, is still a work in progress and hasn’t pitched a whole lot.
Schmidt’s injury doesn’t just hurt — it forces Brian Cashman’s hand ahead of the trade deadline whether he’s ready or not.
Yankees Must Shift into Aggressive Trade Mode
With October aspirations hanging in the balance, the Yankees must now explore external options to fortify the rotation fast.
They’ll need someone who can pitch meaningful innings in August and September — and possibly even game one of a series.
Replacing a starter like Schmidt is difficult not because of flash, but because of trust — and trust is earned, not acquired.
Schmidt had earned it, finally, and now the Yankees are left scrambling to patch yet another hole.
This situation is a reminder: in baseball, depth is not a luxury — it’s a lifeline. And the Yankees just lost another thread.
An Unfair Twist for Clarke Schmidt
For Schmidt personally, this is a cruel twist — he was finally establishing himself, only to have the rug pulled again.
The recovery from Tommy John isn’t just physical. For pitchers like Schmidt, it means battling to reclaim rhythm and confidence.
It may be 2026 before Schmidt is back to full strength, a timeline that feels brutally long for a player hitting his stride.
He had shown resilience rebounding from earlier setbacks, but this one cuts deeper, especially given how well he’d been pitching.
For a guy who’d waited his turn and fought through injuries before, this one feels like getting tackled at the one-yard line.
The Yankees will move on, as they always do, but losing Clarke Schmidt changes their trajectory in ways still hard to define.
READ MORE: Yankees’ Mock Trade: Landing starter and familiar infield upgrade
!function(){var g=window;g.googletag=g.googletag||{},g.googletag.cmd=g.googletag.cmd||[],g.googletag.cmd.push(function(){g.googletag.pubads().setTargeting(“has-featured-video”,”true”)})}();