The New York Yankees had a chance to tighten the AL East race but instead unraveled in a frustrating 4-1 loss to Toronto.
Carlos Rodon wasn’t sharp, the defense crumbled, and the offense never found rhythm as the Yankees slipped four games back.
It felt like one of those games where everything teetered just slightly off—enough to cost a critical divisional matchup.
The defeat stung more because the Yankees led early and handed the game over with unforced errors in the fifth.
Sloppy fifth inning costs Yankees dearly
Giancarlo Stanton’s solo blast in the fourth gave the Yankees a 1-0 lead and brief momentum against Kevin Gausman.
But in the very next inning, Carlos Rodon opened the door with a leadoff walk to George Springer.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. followed with a single, and then Bo Bichette flipped the game with a sharp two-run double.
Rodon seemed to regain command, retiring Alejandro Kirk and Davis Schneider in succession to nearly escape the jam.
Then came the gut-punch: Oswald Peraza’s wide throw on what should’ve been the third out allowed another run.
Peraza throws away what would have been the third out and the Blue Jays add another run, 3-1 pic.twitter.com/ve5ElWY6UK
— Talkin’ Yanks (@TalkinYanks) July 22, 2025
Anthony Volpe compounded the problem with his own defensive miscue, letting Toronto score a fourth and final time.
In a matter of minutes, a winnable game transformed into an uphill climb, largely due to avoidable mistakes.
Carlos Rodon wobbles through five uneven innings
Rodon’s numbers weren’t catastrophic, but they told the story of a pitcher battling himself more than the opponent.
The lefty walked five, allowed six hits, and struck out four—far from the dominance the Yankees expect from him.
Even without the errors, Rodon lacked the command that has made him a steady presence with his 3.10 ERA this year.
His fastball command drifted and secondary pitches rarely landed where he wanted, especially against right-handed hitters.
The Yankees need more from their top arms in big divisional matchups.
Much like a chess grandmaster misplacing their queen early, Rodon’s early walks left no margin for error later.
Giancarlo Stanton continues quiet surge
If there’s a silver lining to the loss, it’s the continued resurgence of Giancarlo Stanton’s powerful right-handed bat.
His home run off Gausman wasn’t just loud—it was timely, majestic, and a reminder of how dangerous he still is.
That was Stanton’s fifth homer of the season, and each one has carried emotional weight after his brutal elbow injuries.
Notably, this long ball came against a tough right-hander, a matchup that usually challenges Stanton at this stage of his career.
Now hitting .284 with a .882 OPS, Stanton is giving the Yankees a middle-of-the-order presence they desperately need.
Whether it lasts or not, Stanton’s current form adds some much-needed thump to a lineup that’s often gone silent.
Defensive lapses becoming a concern
It wasn’t just a one-off for the Yankees’ defense—Peraza and Volpe’s miscues highlight a broader concern lately.
Volpe’s error was his 12th of the season, and while his range and athleticism remain elite, the throws have wavered.
Peraza, still trying to prove himself as a long-term big leaguer, can’t afford high-profile mistakes in tight games.
Championship-caliber teams don’t hand away runs; the Yankees just gifted Toronto a couple in a divisional showdown.
Even one clean play could’ve kept the game close—or possibly in New York’s control heading into the late innings.
Margin for error is shrinking in AL East
The Yankees came into this series hoping to trim the deficit and build momentum in the second half of the season.
Instead, they’re now four games back, with the Blue Jays gaining confidence and still leading the way.
Every divisional game feels like a playoff preview, and the Yankees can’t afford to keep dropping winnable matchups.
There’s still time to climb, but games like this will linger if the standings stay tight in September.
With Rodon struggling, the defense faltering, and the bats cold outside of Stanton, urgency is starting to creep in.
READ MORE: Yankees linked to new trade target having a bounce-back season
!function(){var g=window;g.googletag=g.googletag||{},g.googletag.cmd=g.googletag.cmd||[],g.googletag.cmd.push(function(){g.googletag.pubads().setTargeting(“has-featured-video”,”true”)})}();