The Yankees were already limping through June, but Thursday’s game against the Toronto Blue Jays twisted the knife deeper.
After losing their grip on first place for the first time all season, they were just swept by Toronto in crushing fashion.
Clarke Schmidt’s injury sends a chilling ripple through the rotation
The real gut punch came when Clarke Schmidt left after only 55 pitches, gripping his right forearm in obvious discomfort.
Schmidt has been one of the Yankees’ most reliable arms this year, boasting a 3.32 ERA over 78.2 innings in 2025.
Losing him now feels like pulling the last Jenga block from an already wobbly tower — the whole thing might collapse.
The Yankees simply can’t withstand more blows to the staff
This rotation was already missing Ryan Yarbrough, and the Yankees were clinging to hopes of getting Luis Gil back soon.
Now they’re staring at an even thinner group, with no real outside help waiting in the wings at the major league level.
That’s terrifying for a team whose offense has gone ice-cold, scoring inconsistently right when they needed production most.
Minor league arms might be forced to step up sooner
If Schmidt does miss time — and forearm tightness almost guarantees it — the Yankees may call on Allan Winans again.
However, surging prospect Cam Schlittler is also on their radar. At 24, he’s pitching to a 2.82 ERA in the minors this season.
That includes a 3.80 ERA over 23.2 innings in Triple-A, a small but promising sample that shows he’s knocking on the door.
Schlittler still needs seasoning, complicating the picture
Schlittler is a bright spot for the future, but the Yankees might not want to rush him with so much at stake right now.
His development is critical, and leaning too heavily on him in a tight division race could do more harm than good.
In many ways, it’s like expecting a college kid to manage a family’s entire mortgage — admirable, but unfairly risky.
Trade deadline looms, but costs will be steep
The Yankees could look to the market later this month to shore up the rotation, but it won’t be cheap.
Pitching is always a premium at the deadline, and New York also needs serious infield help if they want to make a real run.
The front office might soon face tough choices about whether to drain the farm for another starter or ride it out.
- The Yankees’ starting rotation just suffered a catastrophic blow
- Yankees 5, Blue Jays 8: Good news and bad news as Yanks lose Clarke Schmidt and get swept
- Yankees’ key starting pitcher goes down with forearm injury
The Yankees’ season hangs by a thread
This injury couldn’t come at a worse time. The Yankees are reeling, their lineup scuffling, and the rotation is paper thin.
Schmidt’s status will determine just how desperate Brian Cashman gets over the next few weeks.
!function(){var g=window;g.googletag=g.googletag||{},g.googletag.cmd=g.googletag.cmd||[],g.googletag.cmd.push(function(){g.googletag.pubads().setTargeting(“has-featured-video”,”true”)})}();