• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
New York Sports Today

New York Sports Today

New York Sports News Continuously updated

  • Football
    • Giants
    • Jets
    • Guardians
  • Baseball
    • Mets
    • Yankees
  • Basketball
    • Knicks
    • Nets
    • Liberty
  • Hockey
    • Devils
    • Islanders
    • Rangers
  • Soccer
    • Gotham FC
    • NYC FC
    • NYC FC 2
    • Red Bulls
    • Red Bulls 2
  • Colleges
    • Army
    • Fordham
    • Manhattan College
    • Rutgers
    • Seton Hall
    • St John’s
    • Syracuse
    • University of Connecticut
  • Team Stores

NY Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays: The war for the AL East’s soul

September 5, 2025 by Elite Sports NY

The Yankees would love to forget their last two series with the Blue Jays and in a series this important, they have no choice.

New York last faced the Jays in July and lost two out of three in Toronto, and were also swept clean out of the Rogers Centre in a four-game set June 30-July 3. Forget that the Yankees mostly lost because of a perfect storm of Aaron Judge’s elbow injury, a faulty bullpen, and Anthony Volpe’s defense at shortstop. The lead has shrunk to three games and first place in the AL East within reach.

The New York Yankees know it but we’re going to say it anyway. This weekend? There is no room for careless mistakes.

Time: 7:05 p.m. ET

TV: YES

Betting Line: Yankees -1.5 (-135), O/U 8.5

Key Storyline: Can Yankees finally slay the Jays? The one downside for the Yankees is that even if they sweep Toronto this weekend, they’ll still lose the season series 7-6. That means that in the event of a tie atop the AL East at the end of the season, New York gets bumped down to the Wild Card. We can safely assume that’s barely on the Yankees’ mind, at least in the short-term.

Rather, this is about working good at-bats, making pitches, and playing clean, crisp defense. Don’t worry about getting swept and playing the worst baseball of the season pre All-Star Break. It’s the sprint to the finish line. The playoffs are within reach and so is the division. This weekend, it’s all baseball and all business.

Pitching Matchup: Kevin Gausman (8-10, 3.75 ERA) vs. Cam Schlittler (2-2, 2.61 ERA). Friday’s series opener largely depends on which version of Gausman takes the mound at Yankee Stadium. The veteran righty is either lights-out or getting lit up against the Yankees, owning an 11-10 record and 3.78 ERA in 38 games (32 starts) against the Bombers. This season, he’s faced them three times and gone 1-1 with a 5.52 ERA, including seven innings of one-run ball back on July 21.

However, though Gausman has managed a 3.11 ERA since July 1, the rookie Schlittler continues to pitch well for New York. He posted a 1.60 ERA and 3.14 FIP in August and is fearless with velocity that touches 100 mph. Schlittler has also shown growing confidence in his slider and curveball.

What’s more, Schlittler’s second career MLB start came against the Jays in Toronto on July 22. He pitched five innings of two-run ball with three walks and strikeouts each in a no-decision. His primary goal tonight is to keep those walks down.

X-Factor: Aaron Judge. Aaron Judge is a .301 career hitter against to Toronto and could very well win his third MVP trophy despite Cal Raleigh’s breakout year. The downside is that Judge’s elbow is clearly still sore. He’s only batting .242 since returning from the injured list. The OPS is strong at .888 and he’s taking his walks, but the usual Judge confidence just isn’t there.

Granted, there have been small signs of Judge turning things around. He’s batting .303 in his last ten games with three home runs and is making throws from the outfield in pregame warmups. A big game from him on Friday would give the Yankees some much-needed early momentum.

Prediction. It’ll be interesting to see which version of the Blue Jays arrives in the Bronx this weekend. Toronto lost two of three to the MLB-best Milwaukee Brewers before taking two of three in Cincinnati. However, their arms visibly struggled against the Reds’ feisty lineup. New York’s big bats aren’t exactly a cooldown lap.

However, if you’re browsing New York sports betting apps or New Jersey online casinos, this might best be a parlay game. Bet on George Springer and Cody Bellinger to get at least a hit each. Maybe two or more total bases for Springer. The over on Cam Schlittler’s strikeouts could also be a good pick. But in terms of a score? Yankees and the over in a squeaker seems appropriate. Yankees 7, Blue Jays 6.

FOR FULL STORY ON STANDARD WEBSITE: NY Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays: The war for the AL East’s soul | Elite Sports NY

Filed Under: Yankees

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Andrew Thomas’ major Giants step unlikely to be enough for Week 1 return
  • Mets fan snatches ball from ‘old guy’ in disturbing Citi Field scene
  • 10 things to watch in Giants vs. Commanders
  • Yankees’ captain returns to right field ahead of AL East showdown
  • Yankees announce lineup for series opener vs. Jays with 3 young cornerstones on the bench

Categories

Archives

Our Partners

All Sports

  • 247 Sports
  • Bleacher Report
  • Elite Sports NY
  • Empire Sports Media
  • Empire Writes Back
  • MSG Networks
  • New York Daily News
  • New York Times
  • New York Post
  • Newsday
  • OurSports Central
  • SNY - SportsNet New York
  • The Sports Daily
  • The Sports Fan Journal
  • The Spun
  • USA Today
  • WFAN Sports Radio
  • YES Network

Baseball

  • MLB.com - Yankees
  • MLB.com - Mets
  • Amazin Avenue
  • Last Word On Baseball - Mets
  • Last Word On Baseball - Yankees
  • MLB Trade Rumors - Yankees
  • MLB Trade Rumors - Mets
  • Rising Apple
  • Yanks Go Yard

Basketball

  • NBA.com - Knicks
  • NBA.com - Nets
  • Amico Hoops - Knicks
  • Amico Hoops - Nets
  • Daily Knicks
  • Hoops Hype - Knicks
  • Hoops Hype - Nets
  • Hoops Rumors - Knicks
  • Hoops Rumors - Nets
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - New York Knicks
  • Last Word On Pro Basketball - Brooklyn Nets
  • Nets Daily
  • Nets Wire
  • Nothing But Nets
  • Posting And Toasting
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Knicks
  • Pro Basketball Talk - Nets
  • Real GM - Knicks
  • Real GM - Nets

Football

  • New York Giants
  • New York Jets
  • Big Blue Interactive
  • Big Blue View
  • Gang Green Nation
  • Giants Gab
  • Giants Wire
  • Gmen HQ
  • Jets Fix
  • Jets Gab
  • Jet Nation
  • Jets Wire
  • Last Word On Pro Football - New York Giants
  • Last Word On Pro Football - New York Jets
  • NFL Trade Rumors - Giants
  • NFL Trade Rumors - Jets
  • Our Turf Football - Giants
  • Our Turf Football - Jets
  • Pro Football Focus - Giants
  • Pro Football Focus - Jets
  • Pro Football Rumors - Giants
  • Pro Football Rumors - Jets
  • Pro Football Talk - Giants
  • Pro Football Talk - Jets
  • The Gang Green
  • The Jet Press
  • Total Giants
  • Total Jets
  • Turn On The Jets
  • Ultimate NYG

Hockey

  • All About The Jersey
  • Blue Line Station
  • Blue Shirt Banter
  • Elite Prospects - Devils
  • Elite Prospects - Islanders
  • Elite Prospects - Rangers
  • Eyes On Isles
  • Last Word On Hockey - Devils
  • Last Word On Hockey - Islanders
  • Last Word On Hockey - Rangers
  • Lighthouse Hockey
  • Pro Hockey Rumors - Devils
  • Pro Hockey Rumors - Islanders
  • Pro Hockey Rumors - Rangers
  • Pro Hockey Talk - Devils
  • Pro Hockey Talk - Islanders
  • Pro Hockey Talk - Rangers
  • Pucks And Pitchforks
  • The Hockey Writers - Devils
  • The Hockey Writers - Islanders
  • The Hockey Writers - Rangers

Soccer

  • Last Word on Soccer - NYC FC
  • Last Word on Soccer - Red Bulls
  • Last Word on Soccer - Sky Blue FC
  • MLS Multiplex - NYC FC
  • MLS Multiplex - Red Bulls
  • Once A Metro

Colleges

  • Against All Enemies
  • Big East Coast Bias
  • Busting Brackets
  • College Football News
  • College Sports Madness
  • Forgotten 5
  • Inside The Loud House
  • Orange Fizz
  • Rumble In The Garden
  • Saturday Blitz
  • The Daily Orange
  • The UConn Blog
  • Troy Nunes Is An Absolute Magician
  • Zags Blog

Footer

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in