The Yankees have plenty of holes they’ll need to fill in the coming days. The club has been in desperate need of help at third base dating back to the offseason, and injuries to the pitching staff have created issues with both the rotation and bullpen as well. One option the club could consider to address those concerns, according to Joel Sherman of the New York Post, would be shopping slugger Ben Rice. Sherman writes that Rice has drawn interest from multiple teams and could be dealt as a way to address needs on the big league roster without dipping into the club’s farm system, though he adds that the Yankees would need to receive a big offer before they’d “even consider” parting ways with the 26-year-old.
It’s not hard to see why the Yankees would be reluctant to part ways with Rice. His second season in the majors has gone extremely well as he’s slashed a strong .232/.323/.468 (121 wRC+) across 84 games to go with even better expected numbers. A solid 9.1% walk rate in conjunction with his 20.6% strikeout rate and 30-homer power makes Rice one of the most intriguing young sluggers in the game, and the fact that he remains under team control for five more seasons after this one should only serve to further elevate his trade value.
With that being said, incumbent first baseman Paul Goldschmidt is a free agent after the 2025 season. The Yankees have an aging and expensive roster, so parting with a young, controllable asset who’s already proven himself to be a capable big league regular could be hard for the team to stomach, especially with a hole at a position he’s capable of handling set to open up in time for Opening Day 2026. To justify not only losing Rice but having to figure out a new long-term plan for the first base position, the Yankees would likely need to get a quality, controllable return in order for a deal to make sense. Teams like the Twins and Marlins could balk at giving up a high-end piece like Joe Ryan or Edward Cabrera for Rice, however, given that much of his production is concentrated within an incredible month of April. Since the calendar flipped to May, Rice has been rather pedestrian with a slash line of just .215/.297/.409 across his last 57 games.
One potential way that likely gap in perceived value could be bridged is if a rival club viewed Rice as a viable catcher. Sherman suggests that multiple teams have “inquired” regarding his viability at the position. The Yankees have Austin Wells entrenched as their everyday catcher, and J.C. Escarra has emerged as a viable backup this year. That leaves Rice to get only occasional time behind the plate with the majority of his work focused on first base and DH in the Bronx; he’s caught just 46 2/3 innings behind the plate with five starts and only two complete games. If a team views Rice as a viable option to catch on at least a semi-regular basis, that could pave the way for a team to value him as highly as the Yankees seem to.
Sherman suggests the Diamondbacks as one potential trade partner who could be intrigued by Rice, and it’s not hard to see why. Arizona traded first baseman Josh Naylor away just last night, and while Pavin Smith is a viable first base and DH option in his own right that would nonetheless open up playing time for Rice in the short-term. Sherman also adds that the Snakes “would like” to bring in catching help thanks to the recent injury history of primary backstop Gabriel Moreno. The 25-year-old is a Gold Glove winner behind the plate with consistently above average offense, but has appeared in just 150 games since the start of the 2024 season due to hand, adductor, and thumb injuries.
That could make Arizona an excellent fit for Rice, if he were to be dealt. Should the Diamondbacks be intrigued by the possibility that he could contribute behind the plate, they could utilize Rice on an occasional basis at the position down the stretch this year and head into the offseason better informed about whether he can stick as a catcher. Even if Rice didn’t pan out as a catcher in Arizona, they already have a hole to fill in their first base and DH mix that Rice could slide into seamlessly. That would allow Rice to serve as a long-term replacement for Naylor (who was himself a short-term replacement for longtime first baseman Christian Walker this past winter) even if he doesn’t work out as a catcher.
Of course, this is all largely speculative. The Diamondbacks are known to be prioritizing pitching this summer, and their roster is already extremely left-handed with Smith, Corbin Carroll, Jake McCarthy, and Alek Thomas all batting from the left side to say nothing of switch-hitters Geraldo Perdomo and Ketel Marte. If the Snakes were to add a hitter, they might prefer one who bats righty. That’s an especially noteworthy consideration given that Eugenio Suarez, Randal Grichuk, and Lourdes Gurriel Jr. are all right-handed bats who have been discussed as potential trade candidates. Of that trio, only Gurriel is controlled beyond 2025.