The New York Mets are flirting with disaster by forcing Jorge Polanco to learn first base on the fly, a defensive gamble that smells like desperation rather than strategy.
With Pete Alonso taking his 40 home runs to Baltimore for $155 million, the Mets have left a crater in the middle of their lineup that a converted second baseman simply cannot fill. However, David Stearns has a golden opportunity to execute a classic “buy low” heist by trading for Tampa Bay Rays slugger Yandy Díaz, a move that provides 90% of Alonso’s offensive production for less than 10% of the financial headache.
Díaz is currently sitting on a 2026 club option worth just $12 million, a laughable sum for a player who just won a batting title two seasons ago and remains an on-base machine. The Rays, perpetually allergic to paying veterans, are likely looking to shed salary, making Díaz the ideal target for a Mets team that needs a professional hitter to stabilize the infield without blocking future flexibility.
A “Monster Bat” That Replaces the Polar Bear
Critics will point to Díaz’s age—he turns 35 next season—but his 2025 campaign proved there is plenty of gas left in the tank. The veteran slashed .300/.366/.482 over 150 games, launching 25 home runs and driving in 83 runs while maintaining the elite plate discipline that has defined his career. He offers a different flavor of offense than Alonso; where Pete provided raw power and strikeouts, Díaz provides consistent contact and a refusal to chase pitches out of the zone.
While the Mets are currently playing a dangerous game with Jorge Polanco as a defensive nightmare at first base, acquiring Díaz allows Polanco to shift back to the designated hitter role where he belongs. It restores balance to the roster, giving manager Carlos Mendoza a legitimate first baseman who, while not a Gold Glover, has actually played the position at the major league level.
The algorithm hides the best Mets news; make sure you pin Empire Sports Media on Google News so you don’t miss a beat.
The Defense Is Bad, But Is It Worse Than Pete?
Let’s be honest: Yandy Díaz is not going to win any defensive awards, and his range at first base is limited at best. But we need to stop pretending that Pete Alonso was Keith Hernandez over there; Alonso posted negative defensive metrics himself last season, meaning the drop-off from “bad” to “also bad” is negligible.
If the Mets can stomach mediocre defense from a $155 million player, they can certainly tolerate it from a guy making $12 million who gets on base at a .360 clip.
The alternative is relying on internal options like Mark Vientos, but with reports surfacing that the Mets are reportedly open to trading Mark Vientos, the internal bridge seems shaky at best. Díaz represents a known commodity who thrives in big moments and wouldn’t be intimidated by the New York spotlight.
Looking Ahead: A No-Brainer for Stearns
Trading for Yandy Díaz is the kind of shrewd, high-floor move that defines winning front offices. He replaces the offensive void left by Alonso, pushes Polanco to his optimal DH spot, and costs a fraction of what a free agent would demand.
The Mets need a sure thing in a lineup full of question marks, and grabbing the Tampa Bay hit machine is the smartest way to ensure they aren’t punting the season before it even begins.